which of the following measurements has the greatest precision

Daniel Parker

2 min read

·

23-02-2025

1

0

Share

Which Measurement Has the Greatest Precision? Understanding Precision in Measurement

Precision in measurement refers to how close repeated measurements of the same quantity are to each other. It's about the reproducibility of a measurement, not necessarily its accuracy (how close the measurement is to the true value). A measurement with high precision shows little variation between repeated trials, even if those trials are far from the actual value. Conversely, a measurement with low precision shows significant variation between trials.

To determine which measurement has the greatest precision from a given set, we need to look at the spread or variation in the measurements. Several methods can help us assess this.

1. Analyzing the Data Directly:

Let's say we have the following sets of measurements for the same quantity:

• Set A: 10.0 cm, 10.1 cm, 10.2 cm, 9.9 cm
• Set B: 9.8 cm, 9.9 cm, 9.9 cm, 10.0 cm
• Set C: 15.2 cm, 10.1 cm, 12.3 cm, 8.7 cm

Looking at Set A, the measurements vary by 0.3 cm. In Set B, the measurements vary only by 0.2 cm. Set C shows the largest variation at 6.5 cm. Therefore, based on a simple visual inspection, Set B shows the greatest precision because its measurements cluster most closely together.

2. Calculating the Range:

The range is the difference between the highest and lowest measurements in a data set. A smaller range indicates greater precision.

• Set A Range: 10.2 cm - 9.9 cm = 0.3 cm
• Set B Range: 10.0 cm - 9.8 cm = 0.2 cm
• Set C Range: 15.2 cm - 8.7 cm = 6.5 cm

Again, Set B has the smallest range, and thus the greatest precision.

3. Calculating the Standard Deviation:

Standard deviation is a more robust measure of precision than the range. It accounts for the spread of all the measurements around the mean (average). A smaller standard deviation means greater precision. Calculating standard deviation involves several steps, and it's often easiest to use a calculator or statistical software.

(The calculation of standard deviation is beyond the scope of this simple explanation, but numerous online calculators and statistical software packages can easily perform this calculation.)

4. Significant Figures:

The number of significant figures in a measurement reflects the precision of the measuring instrument. A measurement with more significant figures is generally considered more precise. For instance:

• 10.00 cm has greater precision than 10 cm.
• 0.001 g has greater precision than 0.1 g.

Important Considerations:

• Accuracy vs. Precision: High precision doesn't guarantee high accuracy. Measurements can be very precise (close to each other) but far from the true value.
• Measurement Errors: Random errors affect precision, while systematic errors affect accuracy.
• Instrument Limitations: The precision of a measurement is limited by the precision of the instrument used.

In summary, determining the greatest precision among multiple measurements requires analyzing the spread of the data. While a visual inspection can often suffice for simple sets, calculations such as range and, more accurately, standard deviation provide a more quantitative assessment of precision. The number of significant figures also offers a clue to the instrument's precision. Always remember that precision and accuracy are distinct concepts.