more fair or fairer

Daniel Parker

2 min read

·

28-02-2025

1

0

Share

More Fair or Fairer: A Deep Dive into Comparative Adjectives

The question of whether to use "more fair" or "fairer" often arises when discussing fairness. Both options are grammatically correct, but choosing between them depends on style, context, and personal preference. This article will explore the nuances of each option, helping you select the most appropriate choice for your writing.

Understanding Comparative Adjectives

Before diving into the specifics of "fair" vs. "fairer," let's establish a foundational understanding of comparative adjectives. Comparative adjectives are used to compare two or more nouns. They describe which noun possesses a particular quality to a greater or lesser degree. Many adjectives form their comparative form by adding "-er" (e.g., taller, shorter, faster). Others use "more" + adjective (e.g., more intelligent, more beautiful, more difficult).

The Case of "Fair"

"Fair" is a bit of a unique adjective. It's a relatively short word, and grammatically, it can accept either the "-er" suffix or the "more" construction to form its comparative form. This flexibility leads to the question of which option is "better."

"Fairer": The Traditional and More Common Approach

"Fairer" is the more traditional and commonly used comparative form of "fair." It's concise, elegant, and flows naturally in most sentences. This makes it the preferred choice for many writers. For example:

• "This solution is fairer than the previous one."
• "She felt that the judge's ruling was fairer to the defendant."

The simplicity and euphony of "fairer" contribute to its widespread acceptance. It avoids any potential awkwardness that "more fair" might create in certain sentence structures.

"More Fair": A Valid Alternative

While "fairer" is generally preferred, using "more fair" is not grammatically incorrect. This option is often used when aiming for a slightly more formal or emphatic tone. It might also be used to avoid the slight rhythmic irregularity that "fairer" can produce within a sentence. Consider these examples:

• "The new policy is more fair to all employees."
• "A more fair distribution of resources is necessary."

The use of "more fair" can sometimes enhance clarity, especially when the sentence already contains several "-er" comparatives. Using "more fair" creates a better balance and avoids a repetitive rhythm.

Choosing Between "More Fair" and "Fairer": A Practical Guide

Here's a helpful guide to aid your decision-making:

• Conciseness: If brevity is key, "fairer" is usually the better option.
• Formal vs. Informal: "Fairer" tends to be more common in informal writing, while "more fair" might be preferred in formal contexts.
• Rhythm and Flow: Consider how each option sounds within the sentence. If "fairer" sounds awkward, "more fair" might be a better fit.
• Personal Preference: Ultimately, the choice is sometimes a matter of personal style and preference.

Conclusion: Context is King

The ultimate decision of using "more fair" or "fairer" depends heavily on the specific context. Both options are acceptable, but understanding the nuances of each will help you choose the form that best suits your writing style and the overall tone of your work. By considering the factors outlined above, you can ensure clarity, elegance, and effective communication in your writing. The key takeaway is that neither option is inherently "wrong"; the right choice depends on the particular sentence and the desired effect.