james conner or david montgomery draft

Daniel Parker

2 min read

·

21-02-2025

10

0

Share

James Conner vs. David Montgomery: A Draft Day Dilemma

The NFL draft is a time of excitement, anticipation, and difficult decisions. This year, fantasy football managers and NFL GMs alike face a tough choice in the later rounds: James Conner or David Montgomery? Both running backs offer intriguing potential, but also carry significant risk. This article will delve into a comprehensive comparison of both players, helping you make an informed decision on draft day.

James Conner: The Proven Producer with Injury Concerns

Conner, a veteran back for the Arizona Cardinals, has a proven track record in the NFL. He's demonstrated an ability to be a lead back and produce consistent fantasy points when healthy. However, his injury history is a significant concern. He's missed games due to various ailments throughout his career, creating uncertainty regarding his availability.

Strengths:

• Proven Production: Conner has multiple seasons with over 1,000 total yards and double-digit touchdowns.
• Goal-Line Prowess: He's a reliable red-zone threat, capitalizing on scoring opportunities.
• Pass-Catching Ability: Conner is a capable receiver, adding value in PPR leagues.

Weaknesses:

• Injury History: Conner's durability is a major question mark. His injury history significantly impacts his fantasy value.
• Age and Wear and Tear: As a veteran back, his production could decline due to accumulating wear and tear.
• Team Context: Arizona's backfield situation could impact his workload. The addition of a rookie or other free agents could reduce his touches.

David Montgomery: The Workhorse with a Questionable Future

Montgomery, now with the Chicago Bears, has consistently been a high-volume back throughout his career. He's proven his ability to carry a heavy workload, but his overall fantasy production has been inconsistent. His future in Chicago is also uncertain, potentially affecting his value.

Strengths:

• High-Volume Back: Montgomery has consistently received a large number of carries.
• Tough Runner: He's known for his physical running style.
• Potential for Increased Production: With a new team and potentially a more prominent role, his production could increase.

Weaknesses:

• Inconsistency: Montgomery's fantasy output has fluctuated from season to season.
• Lack of Explosive Plays: He doesn't consistently break off big runs.
• Uncertain Team Context: His role in the Bears' offense remains unclear after the team's offseason moves.

Head-to-Head Comparison: Conner vs. Montgomery

Which Player Should You Draft?

The choice between Conner and Montgomery depends on your risk tolerance and your league's scoring format.

• Choose Conner if: You're willing to gamble on a proven talent with higher upside potential when healthy and prefer a more established player. He's likely a safer bet in PPR leagues due to his receiving ability.

• Choose Montgomery if: You prioritize volume and are comfortable with a slightly riskier, higher-variance player with potential for increased production in a fresh environment. He is more likely to be a strong choice in standard scoring leagues.

Ultimately, the best approach is to carefully consider your team's needs, your league's scoring format, and your comfort level with risk. Both players offer intriguing possibilities, but neither guarantees consistent high-level fantasy production. Remember to also factor in your draft position and the other available players at the time of your pick. Good luck!