how did king phillip cause the great schism

Daniel Parker

2 min read

·

28-02-2025

1

0

Share

How Did King Philip IV Cause the Great Schism? The Role of Power and Politics

The Great Schism (1378-1417), a period of division within the Catholic Church featuring rival popes, wasn't solely caused by theological disputes. Political maneuvering, particularly by King Philip IV of France, played a crucial role in igniting and prolonging this tumultuous era. While pre-existing tensions undoubtedly contributed, Philip's actions significantly exacerbated the situation, ultimately leading to the election of two, then three, competing popes.

Philip IV's Conflict with Pope Boniface VIII

The seeds of the schism were sown in the late 13th and early 14th centuries during the reign of Pope Boniface VIII. Boniface, asserting papal supremacy, clashed repeatedly with Philip IV over taxation and royal authority. Philip, aiming to consolidate his power and control over French finances, resisted Boniface's claims. This conflict escalated dramatically. Boniface issued the papal bull Unam Sanctam, asserting the pope's supreme authority over both spiritual and temporal matters.

This directly challenged Philip's authority. Philip responded by seizing papal revenues in France and even orchestrating Boniface's arrest (though this attempt failed). The conflict severely damaged the Church's authority. It fostered resentment against the papacy, particularly in France, and created a climate ripe for division.

The Election of Clement V and the Avignon Papacy

After Boniface's death in 1303, Philip exerted significant influence over the papal election. The new pope, Clement V, relocated the papacy to Avignon, in Southern France, a move seen by many as a sign of French domination over the Church. The Avignon Papacy (1309-1376) lasted for nearly seven decades. This period was marked by accusations of French influence corrupting the papacy and undermining its moral authority.

The Avignon papacy, while not directly causing the schism, significantly contributed to it. The long period of French control over the papacy fueled anti-papal sentiment across Europe. This ultimately weakened the papacy's credibility and its ability to unify the Church when the crisis finally erupted.

The Death of Gregory XI and the Election of Urban VI

Upon the death of Gregory XI in 1376, the cardinals, weary of the Avignon Papacy, initially elected an Italian, Urban VI. However, this election didn't fully resolve the underlying tensions. Many cardinals felt pressured into electing Urban, and some quickly regretted their decision. This dissatisfaction, fueled by continued resentment over French influence, played into Philip's hands.

Philip IV and the Counter-Pope: The Schism Begins

Philip IV, sensing an opportunity to maintain French influence, played a key role in the subsequent crisis. He and other French cardinals refused to recognize Urban VI’s legitimacy. They convened a separate conclave and elected a rival pope, Clement VII, setting the stage for the Great Schism. This action had less to do with theological doctrine. It was primarily a political maneuver to challenge what they perceived as an overly assertive Italian papacy and reclaim French dominance.

Philip's actions decisively split the Church. For nearly four decades, the Catholic world was divided, with competing popes issuing contradictory pronouncements and claiming legitimate authority. While various factors contributed to the Great Schism, Philip IV's skillful manipulation of political circumstances and his determination to resist papal overreach proved pivotal in triggering and prolonging the crisis. The schism ultimately highlighted the dangerous entanglement of religious and political power, leaving a lasting impact on the Catholic Church and European politics.