do savior siblings die

Daniel Parker

2 min read

·

26-02-2025

1

0

Share

Do Savior Siblings Die? Understanding the Risks and Realities of Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD)

The term "savior sibling" evokes strong emotions. It refers to a child conceived through Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD) to be a bone marrow or umbilical cord blood donor for a sick sibling. While the intention is to save a life, the question inevitably arises: Do savior siblings die? The answer is complex and requires careful consideration of several factors.

Understanding Savior Siblings and PGD

PGD is a procedure used in IVF (in-vitro fertilization). It involves screening embryos for genetic diseases before implantation. In the case of a savior sibling, embryos are screened not only for disease, but also for Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) compatibility with the sick sibling. A compatible embryo is then implanted, resulting in the birth of a child who can potentially donate life-saving cells or tissues.

The Risks Involved

While PGD is a relatively safe procedure, it's not without risks:

• Miscarriage: IVF and PGD carry a higher risk of miscarriage compared to natural conception. This is a significant emotional and physical burden for the parents.
• Multiple Births: The transfer of multiple embryos increases the chances of twins, triplets, or more. Multiple births pose health risks to both the mother and the babies.
• Ethical Concerns: The ethical implications of creating a child solely for the purpose of benefiting another are widely debated. Concerns exist about the potential for exploitation and the psychological impact on the savior sibling.
• Failure of Treatment: Even if a compatible savior sibling is born, there's no guarantee that the donation will be successful. The sibling's cells might not be a perfect match, or the disease might be too advanced for a cure.

Do savior siblings die at a higher rate than other children? There's no definitive evidence to support this claim. The mortality rate of savior siblings is likely similar to that of children born through IVF, which carries its own set of risks. However, the emotional and psychological well-being of the savior sibling is a critical consideration that requires ongoing support and attention.

The Emotional Toll

The emotional impact on the savior sibling, their parents, and the sick sibling is profound. The savior sibling may grapple with their unique role and the potential for feelings of resentment, guilt, or pressure. Open communication and psychological support are crucial for all family members.

Alternatives to Savior Siblings

It's important to note that PGD is not the only option for treating genetic diseases. Advances in gene therapy and other medical treatments are continually expanding, providing alternative avenues for helping sick children. These options should be carefully explored alongside PGD.

Conclusion: A Complex Issue

The question of whether savior siblings die is not simply a matter of statistics. It encompasses ethical dilemmas, medical risks, and profound emotional consequences. While PGD offers hope for families facing devastating illnesses, it's crucial to weigh the potential benefits against the inherent risks and uncertainties involved. Open discussion, thorough counseling, and careful consideration of all available options are essential before embarking on this path. The well-being of all family members, including the savior sibling, must remain the paramount concern.