disruptive selection definition biology

Daniel Parker

3 min read

·

16-03-2025

1

0

Share

Disruptive selection, also known as diversifying selection, is a mode of natural selection where extreme values for a trait are favored over intermediate values. This leads to a population becoming more diverse, potentially resulting in the formation of new species. Unlike stabilizing selection (favoring the average) or directional selection (favoring one extreme), disruptive selection pushes the population in two (or more) different directions simultaneously. Understanding disruptive selection is crucial to comprehending the complexities of evolution and biodiversity.

What is Disruptive Selection in Biology?

Disruptive selection occurs when environmental conditions favor individuals at both ends of a phenotypic spectrum, while individuals with intermediate phenotypes are at a selective disadvantage. This might occur due to multiple different environmental niches being available or through resource partitioning, where different resources are exploited by different phenotypes. The result? A bimodal distribution—two distinct peaks—in the trait's frequency within the population.

Think of it like this: if you have a population of birds with beaks of varying sizes, and only small seeds and large seeds are available, birds with very small beaks (ideal for small seeds) and very large beaks (ideal for large seeds) will thrive. Birds with medium-sized beaks, however, might struggle to efficiently access either seed type, resulting in lower survival and reproductive rates. This is disruptive selection in action.

How Disruptive Selection Works: Mechanisms and Examples

Several mechanisms can drive disruptive selection. These include:

• Environmental Heterogeneity: A diverse environment with patchy resources can favor different phenotypes in different microhabitats. For instance, a population of insects might have individuals that prefer feeding on different plant species, leading to selection for different mouthpart structures.

• Sexual Selection: Mate choice can also contribute to disruptive selection. If females prefer males with extreme traits (e.g., extremely bright plumage or large antlers), this can lead to a split in the male population, with some exhibiting the extreme trait and others not.

• Predator-Prey Interactions: Predators might preferentially target individuals with intermediate phenotypes, leaving extreme phenotypes less vulnerable. This is known as apostatic selection.

Real-world Examples of Disruptive Selection:

• Darwin's Finches: The classic example! Different beak sizes in Darwin's finches evolved in response to different food sources (seeds of varying sizes) available on the Galapagos Islands.

• African Finches: Studies of Pyrenestes ostrinus, a finch species in Africa, show disruptive selection on beak size. Birds with either very small or very large beaks are more successful at obtaining different types of seeds compared to those with medium-sized beaks.

• Stickleback Fish: Stickleback fish populations in lakes often show disruptive selection on body size. Larger fish are better at competing for resources, while smaller fish are more efficient at avoiding predators.

What is the difference between disruptive selection and directional selection?

While both are forms of natural selection, they differ significantly in their outcome:

• Disruptive selection: Favors both extremes, leading to increased phenotypic variation and potentially speciation.

• Directional selection: Favors one extreme, resulting in a shift of the average phenotype towards that extreme.

The Role of Disruptive Selection in Speciation

Disruptive selection is a crucial driver of speciation, the formation of new and distinct species. As the population splits into two (or more) distinct groups with different traits, reproductive isolation may eventually occur. This means the groups can no longer interbreed and exchange genes freely, leading to the evolution of separate species. Geographic isolation can further enhance this process by physically separating the groups.

Conclusion: The Significance of Disruptive Selection

Disruptive selection, as a potent force in evolution, plays a significant role in shaping biodiversity. By favoring extreme phenotypes, it contributes to the remarkable diversity of life we observe on Earth. This mechanism, along with others, continues to fuel the ongoing process of evolution and adaptation in countless species. Understanding disruptive selection is key to appreciating the intricate interplay of environmental pressures and genetic variation in the development of life's astonishing array of forms.